Which is
the true story of Snowhite?
All of us
know the Disney’s adaptation of this film, but… It really was like this?
The Grimm
brothers version, tells the story in a violent way. In it, the queen tried to
kill Snowhite three times, instead of only one.
In the
first one, the queen tried to hang her with a tie, however, the dwarfs arrived
on time and took the tie away. Within minutes, Snowhite regained her awareness.
The second
time, the queen sold her a poisoned comb. The queen put it on Snowhite’ hair,
and she fainted. Once again the dwarfs took out the poisoned comb from her
hair. Snowhite had only a small injury, so she was saved.
The apple arrived
in the third attempt. From here, the story is similar to the Disney’ one. The
dwarfs thought Snowhite died, and they build a glass ferret to observe her
until the prince arrived. When it happened, the prince fell completely in love
with her, and he asked for permission to take her to his castle, and the dwarfs
accepted. Thanks to the movement during the castle’s road, the piece of apple
went out from her mouth, and Snowhite woke up. The prince wanted to marry with
her, and she accepted; so the wedding’s setout started.
Meanwhile,
the queen asked the magic mirror who was the most beautiful girl in the
kingdom. The mirror answered, that the most beautiful woman was the future
queen, but without revealing that the
girl was Snowhite. When the queen listened to it, she got very angry, but she
didn’t know who could be that woman.
Shortly
after, the queen received a royal wedding’s invitation. In the ceremony, Snowhite
recognize her, and she told the story to her husband. When the prince listened
to it, he ordered to punish her. A pair of iron shoes was created for her. They
were heated red hot, and the queen was ordered to danced with them until she
died.
As we saw in class, Disney’ stories are
adapted those versions to children. However, the Grimm’s versions are very
violent. This is a good resource to work in class with the students. In this
way, we are working the literature, and children learn the different versions
of a tale they already know. Moreover, we can link the different stories with
the alternative endings the student’s propose.
On the other hand, we can tell the
Grimm’ versions to the students of the third cycle of primary, and they could
promote and develop the communicative skills comparing the story they just
learned with the one they already know. =)
Working with different versions of fairy tales can be a good idea for older students. Young learners can feel lost if we try to offer them different versions of their favourite fairy tales. I'd have loved to know about your opinion about Mulan and the way we are organising work in class.
ResponderEliminar